Does an Accident Impact My Car Insurance?

October 28, 2024

Did you have an accident? Whether it's a minor fender bender or a more serious collision, you can’t help but think about how it could affect your car insurance.

Car insurance is there to protect you financially in case of an accident, but you need to understand that being involved in one can also change the way your car insurer looks at your risk profile.

Get an Insurance Quote

Let’s take a look at how an accident can impact your car insurance and what steps you can take to help reduce any negative effects.

Immediate financial consequences

The first thing that comes to mind after an accident is the immediate financial consequences. From repairing your car to addressing potential medical bills, the financial impact can be significant. However, beyond these immediate costs, an accident can affect the price you pay for car insurance long after the repairs are done.

Claiming or not claiming?

When you’re involved in an accident, one of the first questions you’ll ask yourself is whether to file an insurance claim. While car insurance is there to protect you from the financial burden, making a claim can have long-term consequences on your premium. Some drivers opt to pay out of pocket for minor damages if they feel it might prevent their rates from going up, but this decision depends on several factors, including the cost of repairs and your current deductible.

How your premium may be affected

The impact an accident has on your insurance premium depends on several variables, including your driving history, the severity of the accident, and who was found at fault.

Are you at fault?

If you’re found to be at fault in an accident, you’re likely to see an increase in your insurance premium. Why? Car insurance premiums are calculated based on the risk you present to the insurance company. A past accident may indicate a higher likelihood of future accidents, prompting insurers to adjust your rates accordingly. Insurers will usually assess how much fault you bear in the incident. If you’re entirely or mostly responsible, the increase can be more substantial.

Did you know? A single at-fault accident can hike your premiums by as much as 20-50%, depending on the details.
Not-at-fault accidents

Even if you’re not at fault, there’s a chance your premiums could still go up, though the impact is usually less severe. It might seem unfair, but insurance companies can increase your rates if they see you as having a higher risk profile after an accident, even if you weren’t responsible for it. Some insurers are more lenient with not-at-fault claims and may even offer accident forgiveness, so it’s essential to check your policy details.

Accident forgiveness

Many insurers offer what’s known as accident forgiveness. This is a valuable feature that can protect your rates from increasing after your first at-fault accident. Essentially, if you have accident forgiveness, your insurer will "forgive" the accident, and your premium will remain the same as it was prior to the incident. Keep in mind, this is typically available only to customers with a clean driving record and is often limited to one incident.

This feature doesn’t erase the accident from your driving history, and it may still be considered if you have another at-fault accident in the future. Additionally, accident forgiveness doesn’t prevent the accident from being visible to other insurers if you decide to switch companies.

Severity of the accident

It’s not just the fact that you had an accident that matters—it’s also how severe it was. Insurers look at a range of factors, such as the cost of damages, injuries sustained, and whether your vehicle was declared a total loss. For instance, if you’re involved in a minor fender bender with no injuries and minimal vehicle damage, the impact on your premiums might be relatively small. But if the accident results in a significant payout from your insurer, either for property damage or medical expenses, your rates could rise more sharply.

Your driving record

Your driving record plays a significant role in determining how much your insurance will increase after an accident. If you’ve been a safe driver for many years with no prior claims or accidents, your insurer might be more lenient with a rate increase. Conversely, if you’ve had previous claims or tickets on your record, even a minor accident could lead to a significant jump in your premium.

Maintaining a clean driving record is the best way to avoid major price hikes, and many insurers reward safe drivers with lower premiums over time.

Your deductible

Your deductible is the amount you pay out of pocket before your insurance kicks in. If you’ve opted for a high deductible to keep your premiums low, you’ll bear more of the financial burden after an accident, but your insurer’s costs will be lower. As a result, your premiums may not rise as much as someone with a lower deductible.

What you can do to minimize rate increases

If you’re concerned about how an accident will affect your insurance rates, there are several steps you can take to minimize the impact.

Shop around

If your insurer raises your rates after an accident, it’s a good idea to shop around and compare quotes from other companies. While your accident will likely be on record for three to five years, different insurers have different ways of assessing risk, and you may find a better rate elsewhere.

Consider usage-based insurance Some insurers offer usage-based insurance programs, which track your driving habits through a mobile app or device installed in your car. If you’re a safe driver, enrolling in one of these programs can sometimes help offset the impact of an accident by proving to the insurer that you’re a low-risk policyholder.

Look for discounts

After an accident, you should also take advantage of any discounts your insurer offers. Many insurers provide discounts for bundling home and auto policies, having anti-theft devices installed in your car, or being a member of certain professional organizations. These discounts can help lower your premium and ease the financial impact of an accident.

Final thoughts

Being involved in an accident is never fun, and the potential for higher insurance premiums afterward can add to the stress. Understanding how accidents impact your car insurance and what you can do to mitigate the effects can help you navigate the process more effectively.

Always review your policy details, take advantage of features like accident forgiveness, and consider your options carefully before making a claim.